imagebyusing

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, November 13, 2012

Tom Cruise and the Establishment Clause

Posted on 8:29 PM by Unknown

Tom Cruise and the Establishment Clause

By DAVE TARTRE  

PASADENA, Calif. (CN) - How would a prayer at city council meetings in California hold up if the invocation mentioned Tom Cruise or Scientology, a 9th Circuit judge asked.
     "What if someone has an objection, not to Jesus Christ, but to Abraham or Mohammed or Martin Luther, Confucius, Buddha?" Judge Diarmuid O'Scannlain asked. "I mean we can make a long list, Tom Cruise and Scientology. Where do we draw the line?"
     The judge put the amusing hypothetical to a lawyer fighting the recitation of prayers referencing Jesus at the start of every city council meetings in Lancaster, Calif.
     Shelly Rubin and Maureen Feller filed suit over the practice in 2010, but a federal judge in Los Angeles ruled last year that the prayer survived the test laid out by the Supreme Court in 1983.
     Claims about a prayer that makes a single reference to Jesus would require the court to analyze the content of the prayer, but that is barred under Marsh v. Chambers, according to the court.
     "Because plaintiffs do not even claim the April 27 invocation was 'exploited to proselytize or advance any one, or to disparage any other, faith or belief,' this court cannot properly perform such an analysis," U.S. District Judge Dale Fischer wrote.
     Rubin and Feller's attorney, Roger Diamond of Santa Monica, fine-tuned the claim last week before a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit.
     Saying that a pre-meeting invocation is fine, generally, the plaintiffs say that Lancaster violated the establishment clause by more commonly choosing Christian prayers over those of other denominations.
     "In a period of about a year, and the council meets every two weeks, 20 prayers were given in the name of Jesus Christ," Diamond said. "If it were an isolated situation then we might have a different case."
     He added that the appeal does not challenge an isolated event, but rather a city practice that led to repeated references to Jesus Christ.
     Diamond said he thought the California Court of Appeals had gotten it right in its resolution of Rubin v. City of Burbank, which said that references to religious figures during public meetings cannot be made as part of a prayer.
     The 2002 ruling found an establishment clause violation in an invocation given at a Burbank City Council meeting that ended with an expression of gratitude and love "in the name of Jesus Christ."
     Shelley Rubin, one of the plaintiffs in suit against Lancaster case, is the widow of Irv Rubin, who was a plaintiff in the Burbank case.
     Diamond, her attorney, insisted that the court should consider the invocation as government speech, rather than private speech.
     The council controls the agenda, and people cannot come to a council meeting and say anything they want, he said.
     "The government controls the communication there," Diamond said. "You are there for particular city business and the invocation is part of the process."
     Because the council sets the agenda, the invocation is not free speech, Diamond said.
     Someone with business before the council who does not share the beliefs reflected in the invocation may feel marginalized or excluded, resulting in a violation of the First Amendment, regardless of the city's intent.
     U.S. District Judge Jack Zouhary, sitting on the 9th Circuit by designation from the Northern District of Ohio, asked whether it would cure the problem to read invocations that reflect the religious makeup of the community.
     Diamond said that the diversity of religious beliefs in a community simply shows that a First Amendment violation occurs when an official reference is made to a particular religious figure during a public meeting.
     The attorney for Lancaster, Allison Burns of Stradling Yocca Carlson & Rauth, called Diamond's reading of Marsh very narrow.
     It would require "Lancaster to dictate how third-party volunteers pray to their god or gods," she said.
     Under Marsh, the content of the prayer is irrelevant, Burns told the court.
     Lancaster has had different beliefs represented at the invocations, including "a metaphysicist praying to the good trees in the park, an occasion with an Islamic invocation and a Sikh invocation."
     Lancaster does not run afoul of precedent or the U.S. Constitution because Lancaster does not promote any particular religion, she added.
     The city sends out invitations to a variety of congregations for speakers, and that the invitations ask that the "prayer opportunity not be exploited as an effort to convert others to the particular faith of the invocational speaker nor to disparage any faith or belief different from the invocational speaker," Burns said.
     Diamond said he wants a ruling that "the reference to Jesus Christ renders this a sectarian prayer, and under Rubin v. City of Burbank that's a violation by itself."
     "Or, in the alternative, your opinion can say that the reference to Jesus Christ alone was not sufficient by itself, but the fact that over time that prayers continue to be primarily and significantly Christian in nature, that tips the scale in favor of the plaintiffs, requiring that the city disband its practice," he added. "Or you can give the city the option of ordering the speakers to refrain from giving overtly Christian prayers."
     Diamond said that an overtly religious prayer that favors one religion over another "forces people who have business before the city council to feel they are excluded, to feel that, 'Gee, I'm not part of the mainstream here, I don't think I'm going to get a fair hearing before the city council if I'm not part of it."
http://www.courthousenews.com/2012/11/13/52218.htm
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • DAVID MISCAVIGE BELIEVES HE'S GREATER THAN MARTIN LUTHER KING.... EX CELEB SCIENTOLOGISTS MAKING THOSE THAT STAY IN LOOK LIKE BRAINWASHED IDIOTS
    In 2009,  Paul Haggis , the screenwriter-director who won an Oscar for 2005’s  Crash  and wrote  Million Dollar Baby , publicly broke with t...
  • JOE, MATT & KURT FESHBACH: NEW NAMES TO ADD TO THE SCIENTOLOGY SHIT-BAG MONEY GRABBERS LIST
    TOM CRUISE PROFITED FROM THESE  WALL STREET SCUMBAGS AS WELL The Scientology Inc. Gates of Hell Another preview from Chapter Four: Chapter F...
  • UPDATE: GOD DISCUSSES THE BASTARDS RUNNING SCIENTOLOGY
    Media Release: Superstar Women Expose Scientology Crimes Submitted by intelligence on Jan 04, 2013 - 01:04 PM |  The Church of Scientology i...
  • DWARFENFÜHRUR TINYFISTS JOINS TWITTER
    https://twitter.com/DavidMiscavage ‘I feel the need…the need for speed’: Tom Cruise embraces life in the fast lane as he rides a motorbike o...
  • Scientology is evil and scientologists are dangerous.
    Scientology is evil and scientologists are dangerous. By Michael Leonard Tilse Copyright�2012 Michael Leonard Tilse. This essay may be freel...
  • STOP THE PRESSES; MISCAVIGE PETRIFIED OF BUM SEX..... LEAH REMINI'S MENTION OF SCIENTOLOGY ON ELLEN CIRCLES THE GLOBE
    Former Ingleside by the Bay Resident Suing Church of Scientology Posted: Sep 9, 2013 4:58 PM by  Janine Reyes Updated: Sep 9, 2013 11:25 PM ...
  • Few religious organizations can top the Church of Scientology when it comes to secrecy, making it nearly impossible to determine how the church invests its money.
    The Almighty Dollar Are churches good money managers? By  Brian Palmer | Posted Friday, Nov. 9, 2012, at 3:24 PM ET Former oil executive and...
  • DEAR HOLLYWOOD MONEY MEN, STOP EMPLOYING THE TOXIC SCIONS AS YOU'LL GO BANKRUPT!!
    Sony's earnings of $35 million (3.5 billion yen) compared with a loss of 24.6 billion yen in the year-ago period. The entertainment and ...
  • CRUISE HIRED 4 "GUARDS" TO PROTECT SURI? .... something not quite right with that
    Tom Cruise chooses Thanksgiving with Suri over Scientology bookathon (Video) TOM CRUISE NOVEMBER 24, 2012 BY:  RITA WATSON Subscribe Katie H...
  • THE NARCONON SCIENTOLOGY CONNECTION PERFECTLY EXPLAINED
    – Scientology is made up of many different entities, all of which are tightly controlled by its “Sea Organization,” with David Miscavige at ...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (317)
    • ►  September (20)
    • ►  August (32)
    • ►  July (32)
    • ►  June (30)
    • ►  May (31)
    • ►  April (31)
    • ►  March (33)
    • ►  February (49)
    • ►  January (59)
  • ▼  2012 (182)
    • ►  December (48)
    • ▼  November (59)
      • SCIENTOLOGY'S NARCONON QUACK TREATMENT LIKELY CAUS...
      • "CHOMPING AT THE BIT FOR MORE" (secret scion speak...
      • HILARIOUS NEW PISS-TAKE GAME ABOUT SCIENTOLOGY
      • SOCIOPATH MIDGET, DAVID MISCAVIGE, FORCED SCIENTOL...
      • SOME GREAT COMMENTS ON SCIENTOLOGY OUT THERE
      • Londoner Says LA is the Worst Place in the Entire ...
      • PAUL MCKENNA, A PROFESSIONAL HYPNOTIST, SUSSES OUT...
      • CRUISE HIRED 4 "GUARDS" TO PROTECT SURI? .... some...
      • BEFORE PEOPLE MAGAZINE BENT OVER AND TOOK THE SCIO...
      • John Travolta’s Allegedly Gay Penis: A History
      • “I asked him permission to do some Scientology ass...
      • HUBBARD WANTED TO TURN CORFU INTO AN ISLAND OF HOT...
      • REASONS TO BE THANKFUL THIS THANKSGIVING? ... KATI...
      • MORE PROOF THAT ANYTHING THESE CELEB SCIENTOLOGIST...
      • ÛBER SCIENTOLOGIST KELLY PRESTON (TRAVOLTA'S WIFE)...
      • $10M CELEB (NANCY 'BART' CARTWRIGHT) SCIENTOLOGY D...
      • WAIT UNTIL HE FINDS OUT HE WAS TAKEN AWAY FEOM HIS...
      • LIAR LIAR PANTS ON FIRE JUDGE ROBERT BEACH DENIES ...
      • IS SPLITTING FROM SCIENTOLOGY DANGEROUS? NO SHIT S...
      • WHAT IS IT WITH SCIENTOLOGY AND DENTISTS... an ong...
      • Laughing at Scientology's Expense
      • I wonder if Tom is ever going to see Suri again. W...
      • ARE CRUISE AND TRAVOLTA LINKED TO THE COVER-UP OF ...
      • "Scientology, like lots of organized religions ten...
      • STUNNING KICK IN THE BOLLOCKS TO SCIENTOLOGY - THE...
      • LEE BACA - SCIENTOLOGY'S PAID GOON OF A LA LAW OFF...
      • THE BOMBSHELL SET TO DESTROY CRUISE IN JANUARY
      • SCIONS COME BACK WITH DRUG PR CAMPAIGN TO COMBAT T...
      • CRUISE AND TRAVOLTA CAN EXPECT ANOTHER SCIENTOLOGY...
      • A LOVING "FUCK YOU" TO TOM CRUISE FROM HIS (SUPPRE...
      • Tom Cruise and the Establishment Clause
      • THE XENU BATTLE SUIT
      • Howard Stern Goofs on Scientology particularity To...
      • Few religious organizations can top the Church of ...
      • KATIE TRAPPED; STILL LIVING UNDER TOM'S SPELL
      • NET TIGHTENING ON SCIENTOLOGY'S DRUG DEATH-HOUSE, ...
      • TOMKAT PAP & GOS BOLLOCKS (part 2 of 2)
      • Scientology : The Board Game
      • WHY THE HELL DOESN'T LISA MARIE PRESLEY JUST COME ...
      • Well, for starters they believe in Xenu
      • WHEN A FAT SCIENTOLOGIST DEFENDS A CLOSET GAY SCIE...
      • Just some Kate and Suri stuff
      • WHO KNEW THERE'S A SCIENTOLOGY KNOCK-OFF?
      • TOM CRUISE'S NEW BEARD (GIRLFRIEND SURELY, ED?) NAMED
      • Kirstie Alley says Scientology "is the world's big...
      • ANOTHER AMAZING FIRST HAND ACCOUNT OF WHAT IT'S LI...
      • SCIENTOLOGY HISTORY AND FUCKTARDS IN A NUTSHELL
      • CULT CAN AFFORD £6M FOR BIRMINGHAM RENOVATION? ......
      • CHURCH OR CULT? ... kudos to ABC for (at last) doi...
      • DAILY MIRROR UNDERCOVER REPORT FROM 2005 YOU MIGHT...
      • SCIENTOLOGY PR BOTS GETTING IT WRONG...... AGAIN
      • OUT OF ALL THE SHIT THINGS SCIENTOLOGY DOES 'DISCO...
      • I SAID FROM DAY ONE THAT THIS WAS A DUMBASS LAWSUI...
      • SELECTION OF UK NEWSPAPER REVIEWS OF 'THE MASTER'
      • KIRSTIE ALLEY FEEBLY ATTEMPTS DAMAGE CONTROL RE TR...
      • 'FROM SWEATING OUT ALIEN SPIRITS TO LIFTING OBJECT...
      • IF IT TALKS LIKE A SCIENTOLOGIST, GIVES MONEY TO S...
      • TRULY PATHETIC BEHAVIOUR BY SCION OSA TWATS
      • KATIE HOLMES SMILE SAYS IT ALL
    • ►  October (75)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile