Scientology Rehab In Big Legal Trouble: Drugs, Death, And L. Ron Hubbard
BY Christopher Zara | October 26 2012 2:45 PM
Narconon, the controversial drug rehabilitation program that has been linked to the Church of Scientology, is facing its third lawsuit in as many months.
Attorneys for Shirley Gilliam, whose son died at the Narconon Arrowhead center in eastern Oklahoma last October, filed a wrongful death lawsuit on Wednesday. According to the lawsuit, her 32-year-old son, Gabriel Graves, was a patient at the facility when he was found face down and unresponsive in his bed. A heroin addict suffering severe withdrawal symptoms, he had complained of headaches and vomiting but was denied pain medicine or access to a doctor before he died, according to the suit.
Graves was one of three patients who died at Narconon Arrowhead within a year. The families of the other two patients -- Hillary Holten and Stacy Dawn Murphy -- have also filed lawsuits, the first in August and the second earlier this month.
Founded in 1966, Narconon comprises some 100 rehab centers in 44 countries around the world. The facilities employ the harsh and controversial rehabilitation methods of Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard, who believed drug addicts should quit cold turkey and not be weaned off drugs slowly. Reports identifying Narconon as a front group for Scientology date back more than 20 years. On its website, Narconon says that its rehab program was founded on “key principles” established by Hubbard.
However, the parents of Graves and Murphy say they were unaware of Narconon’s association with Scientology. Speaking to reporters this week, Gilliam said her son was in need of immediate help at the time he was admitted, and that she had not had time to research the facility beforehand. She said she paid an upfront fee of $35,000 for her son’s treatment.
In an interview with the Daily, Gary Richards, the attorney who represents Gilliam and Murphy’s parents, said his clients would not have admitted their children to Narconon Arrowhead if they'd known of its Scientology connection. “When they went to the facility, they saw a picture of L. Ron Hubbard hanging on the wall, and asked directly if they were part of Scientology,” he told the Daily. “They were assured that they were not.”
Gilliam added that her son was forced to undergo five-hour saunas, vitamin treatments and exercise while he was going through withdrawal. Moreover, she claims she was told that at least one medical doctor would be on hand 24 hours a day; instead, a physician was only available once a week. On its website, Narconon says it has eight full-time nurses and one doctor on staff.
In an open letter posted on Tulsa’s 2News website in August, Gary Smith, the CEO of Narconon of Oklahoma, insisted that the facility has not violated any laws. He said reports about the patients’ deaths are rife with “inaccuracies” and that reporters have ignored Narconon Arrowhead’s 20-year track record in which the “first 19 years of operation there were no client deaths.”
Added Smith: “Narconon Arrowhead is certified to offer non-medical detox services by the [Oklahoma Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse] and accredited by [the Commission on Accreditation of Rehabilitation Facilities] and has complied fully with all applicable regulations and treatment standards set forth by these two agencies.”
Narconon claims that more than 70 percent of its patients remain drug-free after they complete the program.
An autopsy report for Graves’ death was inconclusive. According to the AP, Pittsburg County sheriff's office are still investigating all three deaths and awaiting the final autopsy and toxicology reports for Murphy.
Gilliam is seeking $75,000 in damages.
McAlester Drug Rehab Center Narconon Targeted In 3rd Wrongful Death Suit
Posted: Oct 24, 2012 7:37 PM BSTUpdated: Oct 24, 2012 11:26 PM BSTBrandi Ball, NewsOn6.com - email
McALESTER, Oklahoma -
Another civil lawsuit has been filed against a Scientology-based northeastern Oklahoma drug and alcohol rehabilitation center, court documents state.
It is the third such lawsuit filed against the facility this year.
The mother of a Claremore man, who died in 2011 while a patient at Narconon Arrowhead near McAlester, filed the latest petition on Thursday in Pittsburg County District Court. The filing comes almost one year to the day that Gabriel Graves, 32, was found dead in his bed.
Graves left behind two minor children. He was treated at the facility for two months before his death, court documents state.
In the lawsuit, Shirley Gilliam alleges her son was the victim of wrongful death, negligence, and violation of the Oklahoma Consumer Protection Act. The suit lists defendants as nonprofit Narconon Arrowhead, Narconon International, the Association for Better Living and Education International and Gerald D. Wootan, medical director of Narconon Arrowhead.
The defendants "all rely exclusively upon the written ‘technology' of L. Ron Hubbard, the founder of the Church of Scientology… despite the fact that Hubbard has no known training or education in the field of drug and alcohol rehabilitation," the lawsuit alleges.
Two other patients died at Narconon Arrowhead this year – a 20-year-old woman from Owasso, Stacy Dawn Murphy, and a Texas woman, Hillary Holten. Murphy's family filed a lawsuit earlier this month, and Holten's family filed in August.
10/05/2012 Related Story: Parents File Lawsuit Against Narconon After Owasso Woman Dies In Treatment
The families of Murphy and Graves are both represented by the same Tulsa law firm.
"Circumstances of the deaths of Gabriel Graves and Stacy Murphy have numerous similarities," attorney Gary Richardson said. "Both of these young adults were addicted to drugs and were introduced to Narconon when they sought treatment. They and their parents were provided misleading information on the Narconon website and by Narconon representatives, which led them to believe that Narconon Arrowhead would be a safe and effective treatment facility."
Richardson takes issue with what he calls a fraudulent misrepresentation of 24-hour physician oversight at the facility.
"Instead, a physician is present only once a week," Richardson said.
According to court documents, Graves was denied doctor's care when requested, and Murphy was found dead in an unsupervised withdrawl unit after she sneaked in drugs following a visit home.
The lawsuit claims Graves experienced symptoms of feeling ill, headaches and vomiting, and repeatedly requested medical assistance. He was never examined by nor referred to a physician, nor transferred to a medical facility equipped to diagnose and appropriately treat his medical symptoms, the petition says.
The day of his death, Graves complained to staff about a headache after spending time in the sauna program, but was denied over-the-counter pain relief and was told to return to the sauna, the suit alleges.
According to the Narconon website, the sauna detox program was developed by Hubbard and is aimed at mobilizing and eliminating foreign compounds stored in fat. Narconon uses "prescribed periods in low-temperature sauna to promote sweating," the website says.
Clients are on the detox program up to five hours a day every day and aside from sauna treatment, components include exercise, vitamin and fluid intake, a regular diet with fresh vegetables and a normally required amount of sleep, the website says.
Narconon says the program rids the body of drug metabolites, which reduce future cravings and promote long-term sobriety.
"Use of this detoxification program at Narconon is based on the premise that drug residues [Cocaine, amphetamine and benzodiazepine metabolites] remain in body tissues long after active use has ceased," the website says.
In an unrelated case, Narconon is being forced to hand over records another Oklahoma family believes will disclose that some employees trade drugs in exchange for sex with patients.
In September, the Oklahoma Supreme Court denied Narconon Arrowhead's request to keep those documents protected.
0 comments:
Post a Comment